iccsa-20-wind

Virtual Testbed: Simulation of Air Flow Around Ship Hull and Its Effect on Ship Motions
git clone https://git.igankevich.com/iccsa-20-wind.git
Log | Files | Refs

review.org (687B)

      1 * DONE Review 1
      2 CLOSED: [2020-06-20 Sat 15:04]
      3 
      4 It would be highly desirable for the authors to provide the overview of the
      5 other works concerning the same topic. It would help to understand the place of
      6 the proposed model in the common row of the models simulating air flow around
      7 ship hull and estimate the anvantages and disadvantages of the presented model.
      8 
      9 * DONE Review 2
     10 CLOSED: [2020-06-20 Sat 15:02]
     11 
     12 The paper is well written and the topic is very interesting.  The only
     13 misunderstanding is about Figure 4 and Table 3. They are at the end of the
     14 paper, but cited in the middle. There are no words about the appendix.  But it
     15 does not influence on the impression of the paper.